Women may be more willing than men to donate organs

Karen Schmidt
American Heart Association News

Men and women have similar reasons for becoming – or not becoming – an organ donor, according to a new study. Yet women appear more willing to donate their organs to fami- ly members or strangers. The results, published Friday in the Journal of the American Heart Association, suggest improving commu- nication among family mem- bers about organ donation wishes could help increase and diversify the pool of organs available for trans- plantation.
“It’s important that we start having these hard con- versations a little earlier,” said Dr. Khadijah Breathett, the study’s senior author, a heart failure and transplant cardiologist and assistant professor of medicine in the Division of Cardiology at the University of Arizona in Tucson. “With COVID, it may be a little easier because people recognize the fragility of life, and not knowing what’s promised
for tomorrow, so these dis- cussions are becoming more common.”
In some states, listing “organ donor” on a driver’s license might not be enough, especially if your family doesn’t know your wishes, Breathett said. To reduce confusion at the
time of death, she encour- ages those who want to donate to sign up on their state’s organ donor registry, inform their family and doc- ument their wishes on a medical power of attorney.

The lack of donated organs remains a major problem: More than 106,000 men, women and children were on the U.S. transplant waiting list as of Sept. 24, according to the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network. Every day, 17 people die waiting for an organ, Department of Health and Human Services statistics show. A person is added to the list every nine minutes. According to a 2019 govern- ment survey, 90% of adults in the U.S. support organ donation but only half are actually signed up as donors.

The new study was designed to delve into organ donation sex disparities, which has not been exten- sively studied before, even though receiving an organ from the opposite sex can lead to worse survival rates, particularly with heart transplants. In the U.S., 60% of living donors – for example, of a kidney or a part of the liver – are women. But only 40% of deceased donors are women.

In the study, “both sexes had similar reasons for wanting to donate their organs,” said lead author Erika Yee, a medical stu- dent at the University of Arizona. “They had a desire to help others. They had personal experiences with organ donors or recipients, or they said they have no

use for their organs after death. So why not donate?”

When people who were not registered donors were asked why, half cited per- sonal fears and more than a third said medical mistrust, with no differences by sex. Other reasons included background knowledge about the transplantation process (33%), religious rea- sons (20%), and wanting their body to be intact for burial (19%). About 40% of men and women said more information might change their willingness to donate. The researchers used a global crowdsourcing mar- ketplace to recruit 667 par- ticipants for a survey in 2019. Researchers can select inclusion and exclu- sion criteria. Eligible partic- ipants can choose to partici- pate based upon their inter- est and the compensation offered, which in this case was $1.

This method provided a “convenience sample,” which inherently lacks ran- domization, and the researchers acknowledged

important differences between the people who chose to participate and the general U.S. population. For example, 69% of the partici- pants were white, 55% were women, 80% were 50 or younger, and 68% had an associate degree or higher.

The authors noted this as a limitation, as well as that a greater proportion of the excluded participants were married and Hispanic eth- nicity.

“Systemic racism and bias are known issues affecting patients of color,” they wrote, “and socioeconomic status also impacts likeli- hood of donation. This study lacks the viewpoint of these important intersec- tional groups.” However, they said, since fewer women become deceased organ donors, the oversam- pling of women is a strength.

Although the study might not be generalizable to the entire U.S. population, it’s important to know people’s reasons for not donating, said Dr. Michael Givertz,

medical director of Heart Transplant and Mechanical Circulatory Support at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston.

Givertz, who was not involved in the study, was surprised that 36% of non- donors cited medical mis- trust as a reason.

“I think that what we do as transplant providers is extremely ethical and trust- worthy,” said Givertz, who is also a professor of medi- cine at Harvard Medical School, “but based on this survey, that’s not always the case, or at least, not widely acknowledged.”

The good news overall, he said, is transplants in the U.S. have been increasing: In 2019, there were 39,719 compared to 30,974 in 2015 and 28,668 in 2010. But demand still greatly out- strips supply. One person’s organs can save eight lives and enhance 75 more lives, according to federal data.

“A single organ donor can give a gift of life to a heart patient, to lung patients, to kidney patients and liver

patients,” Givertz said. “I don’t think people realize that.”

If you have questions or comments about this story, please email editor@heart.org.

Copyright is owned or held by the American Heart Association, Inc., and all rights are reserved. Permission is granted, at no cost and without need for further request, for individ- uals, media outlets, and non-commercial education and awareness efforts to link to, quote, excerpt or reprint from these stories in any medium as long as no text is altered and proper attribution is made to American Heart Association News.

Other uses, including educational products or services sold for profit,
must comply with the American Heart Association’s Copyright Permission Guidelines. See full terms of use. These sto- ries may not be used to pro- mote or endorse a commer- cial product or service.